Researchers Argue Silicon AI Cannot Be Conscious
Three leading consciousness researchers published a commentary in Nature stating that current AI systems are not conscious and likely cannot achieve it on silicon hardware.
Anil Seth, Ned Block, and Giulio Tononi authored a commentary in Nature rejecting the premise that executing specific computations is sufficient for consciousness. They argue that consciousness is defined by subjective experiences that feel like something, a quality distinct from intelligence, which involves carrying out functions. The researchers point to the human cerebellum, which contains nearly four-fifths of all neurons in the brain, as evidence that high-level intelligence does not require consciousness. They also cite AlphaFold, a neural network that predicts protein structures, noting that it is not considered conscious despite its power.
This position contrasts with the 'Consciousness in Artificial Intelligence' report by Patrick Butlin and 17 other experts, including Yoshua Bengio. That report created a checklist of 14 indicators to evaluate AI consciousness and concluded that no current systems, such as GPT-4, are strong candidates. The Butlin report assumed consciousness depends solely on information processing, whereas Seth, Block, and Tononi argue that biological properties are essential. They contend that in biological brains, function and material composition cannot be separated, making the brain-as-computer metaphor problematic.
Anthropic, which reported internal processing patterns in Claude resembling conscious information processing, does not view these as evidence of subjective experience. The company launched a research program on model welfare in April 2025 and allows Claude models to end abusive conversations as a precaution. Seth, Block, and Tononi consider such precautionary measures misguided, arguing that falsely attributing consciousness is far more probable than overlooking actual consciousness in current systems.
Sources
Every sentence of this story was checked against facts quoted from these articles. How we make the news
Spotted an error? Tell us
